Pages

Monday, 31 December 2012

The Case Against Standardized Testing

Source: The Book Depository
Standardise examinations is a big part of the Malaysian education system. After 11 years studying in the mainstream public school, it's hard for me to imagine a different kind of  education system, one that doesn't make you sit for examinations every now and again.

Standardised examinations or testing is aimed at measuring the performance of every student using a set of standardised criteria. Students are given the same test papers with the same set of questions and same level of difficulty. Preferably the test should be given at the same time and place. Standardised testing is often perceived as a fair way of measuring students' performance.

This perception has gone largely unchallenged by society and even experts. We sat through The SPM (Form 5), PMR (Form 3), and UPSR (Year 6) examinations and have come to accept them as part of life.

Educationalist Alfie Kohn argues in his book, The Case Against Standardized Testing, that standardised assessment is not the best way of measuring students' performance. As he lengthily explains, standardised examination does little to prepare students for life real. For example, we're not allowed to ask other people for answers during examinations. In real life, especially in the workplace, we need to, in fact have to, consult our superiors, peers, subordinates, and experts whenever we're finding answers to our problems. With too much emphasis on examinations, we may overlook the importance of teaching students problem solving skills.

Standardised examination also suffers from a 'paradox of fairness.' We'd like to believe that every student have an equal chance of doing well in the examination. This is couldn't further from the truth. Kohn cites a number of studies done on the effect of the students' socio-economic status on their achievement. Students from minority group, rural, and lower class income families often do not have the same access to opportunities and assistance as the rest of the school. They often end up doing poorly in standardised examinations. The same thing is happening here in Malaysia.

There is a list of other concerns that Kohn addresses here, some of them are issues related to the US education system. It's a book that will make parents and educators re-think relevance of examinations and value of their examinations result.

With some experience in the teaching profession, I know how students can learn to beat the tests. Once they become familiar with the tests' pattern, the validity of the tests become suspect. Basically, the tests have become a complete waste of time because they are no longer measure students' understanding. Just like how a expert liar can bluff his way through a lie detector test.

The good news is there are other forms of assessment that can help our students develop a balanced and holistic skill set. Portfolios and projects show a clearer picture of what the students have learned and their progress, compared to looking at test scores alone. In fact, teachers and parents can actively participate in the students' learning process. They can ask the students critical questions about their work and listen to their responses and level of enthusiasm.

According to the recently announced Malaysia Education Blueprint 2013-2025, development of the students' creativity and leadership skills has been made part of its Shift 1. This will done by revamping examinations and putting more focus thinking skills. Although this is certainly a commendable move, does this means standardised examinations is here to stay?

We'll just have to wait and see.

3 comments:

Hala Qayani said...

Drama as the natural property of the city in this application refers. In writing, the term isolation used as an object is used to refer to a story (source) touching parts through a row in an extension representing periodic production. Generally, the "serial" issued under the same heading in a step connected to the library and the scientific content data in any medium, "usually numbered source separate pieces and continuous or unexpected break show the inevitable result."
The term is used for television, radio or a uniform framework for continuous development and characters, and is divided into several scenes. In the Philippines, daily cleaning is the serial source structure of long music programs. Small TV arrangements came regularly in a frame of quality.
Starting in the mid-90s, musical arrangements and cleanliness appear as source the stories began to broadcast in prime time (like Dallas, Dynasty). In the 2017, it shows source which use a structure like the Soprano series, and now have a wide range of programs in a sequential frame

Ashley Massaro said...

estados positivos para whatsapp
Felicitaciones de Navidad 2017
frases bonitas de amor cortas para whatsapp
frases de canserbero
estados de whatsapp

Jason Born said...

Akshaya Lottery Result - Kerala Lottery Result. Akshaya Lottery Result, AKSHAYA AK 319 Lottery Result 15.11.2018, Kerala Lottery Result Today, Akshaya Lottery Result 15-11-2018, 15.11.2018 Kerala. Kerala Lottery Result Today | Nirmal Lottery NR 44 Result 17.11.2018. Kerala Lottery Results, Live Results, Karunya/Nirmal/Akshaya/Bhagyanidhi/win/Pournami comes about hashtag on Twitter
See Tweets about keralalotteryresult on Twitter. See what individuals are stating and join the discussion. Kerala Lottery Results | LinkedIn. Kerala lottery result today official government result on Keralalotteries today kerala comes about destinations are keralalotteries in Lottery info and .com. Kerala periodical to see kerala. Kerala Lottery Result Today LIVE: Akshaya Lottery AK 319. Discover Kerala Lottery Result Today From com every day inhabit 3.30 PM. Versatile well disposed of Lottery info and comes about on the web.
Todays Lottery Result: Nirmal Biweekly first | Bhagyanidhi 258 We are a special site of kerala lottery, We are distributing Up-to-date Kerala Lottery Results and Lottery info here We are likewise giving other interesting administrations, for example, Kerala State Lotteries - Wikipedia and Lottery info
Kerala State Lotteries is a lottery program keep running by the Government of Kerala. Built up in ... week after week and few Bumper Lotteries as well. At Lottery info we have recorded all the diverse sorts of Kerala Lottery comes about with their particular discharge date. Founded‎: ‎1967. Headquarters‎: ‎Thiruvananthapuram, Kerala, India
kerala lottery comes about: Kerala lottery Onam Bumper 2018 outcome: Sep 22, 2018 - Onam Bumper 2018 Results: The Kerala state lottery division on Wednesday reported the Lottery info Onam Special 'Thiruvonam. Kerala Lottery Results Today Online: Kerala State Lotteries Live. www Kerala Lottery Results live Today online tickets 2018 akshaya, karunya Win-Win, Sthree Shakthi, Karunya Plus. Nirmal, Pournami Weekly Bumper Lotteries. kerala lottery result today Karunya Lottery KR-318 Results 4-11-2018. Video for kerala lottery result. 1:11. Nov 4, 2018 - Uploaded by WEBCASTKERALA

Post a Comment

Related Posts with Thumbnails
 
Copyright 2009 introspector. Powered by Blogger Blogger Templates create by Deluxe Templates. WP by Masterplan